Which account first, and what's the tax?
Here's the short version. Required withdrawals start at 73 or 75, depending on when you were born, and they're a slice of last year's balance: about 4% at 75. Before then, which account you draw on sets this year's tax bill. Raising $78,000 costs Dan and Ruth $89 one way and $5,682 another, in 2026 figures.
Federal tax only, 2026 figures. State tax is on top and this page leaves it out.
Meet Dan and Ruth, in their first year
It's 2027, their first year without pay, and neither check has started: Dan waits till 70, Ruth till 67. They need $78,000 to live on. They have $660,000 in 401(k)s and IRAs, $35,000 in Roth accounts and $45,000 in a regular investment account, about half of which is gain. They file jointly. Their numbers are in the form further down. First, the one idea this page turns on.
Dan and Ruth Keller are fictional; their figures are illustrative, not advice for you.
First, the idea: three accounts, three kinds of tax
Money in a 401(k) or regular IRA was never taxed going in, so every dollar that comes out is taxed as income, like pay. Money in a Roth was taxed going in, so it comes out tax-free. Money in a regular investment account was taxed already, so only the gain is taxed when you sell, and at lower rates. Same $78,000 to live on, three different tax bills depending on which door you walk through. That's the whole page.
Then the rule: every year has some free room
Two things make a chunk of income tax-free every year. The standard deduction is $32,200 on a joint return in 2026 ($16,100 single), and income under it isn't taxed at all. And gains from selling in a regular account are taxed at 0% while taxable income stays under $98,900 on a joint return. So for Dan and Ruth in 2027, with no checks yet: sell the regular account first, and the $45,000 is half gain at 0%; take the other $33,089 from the 401(k), and most of it disappears under the standard deduction. Federal tax: $89. Take the whole $78,000 from the 401(k) instead and it's $5,682. The years before Social Security starts are the cheap years, because the free room isn't being used up by the checks. [IRS]
Three things to hold onto
- Required withdrawals start at 73 or 75. 73 if you were born from 1951 to 1959, 75 from 1960 on. (Born in 1959? The rule says 73, but it isn't final.) [IRS]
- How much: last year's balance divided by the IRS number for your age. 26.5 at 73, 24.6 at 75. That's about 4%. Miss it and the penalty is 25%. [Pub 590-B]
- Up to 85% of Social Security gets taxed once your other income passes a line that never moves. $32,000 on a joint return, counting half the benefit; the 85% band starts at $44,000. [Pub 915]
Example 1: raising $78,000 for Dan and Ruth, three ways, then three more years
Here's 2027 as it comes off the calculator, one column for each way of raising the cash:
| Regular account first | 401(k) first, up to the top of the 12% band | A bit of each | |
|---|---|---|---|
| From the regular account | $45,000 | $0 | $5,015 |
| From 401(k)s and IRAs | $33,089 | $83,682 | $73,551 |
| From Roth accounts | $0 | $0 | $3,900 |
| Federal tax | $89 | $5,682 | $4,466 |
| Taxable income | $23,389 | $51,482 | $43,858 |
| Left in 401(k)s and IRAs | $626,911 | $576,318 | $586,449 |
Read the tax row, then the last row. The cheap column this year leaves $51,000 more in the 401(k) than the dear one. That money comes out taxed later, so the cheapest year isn't free; it's deferred. The middle column costs $5,682 and stays inside the 12% band, which is the trade most people are weighing. Now we ran the calculator for three more years of their lives:
| Year | From savings | Cheapest way | Its tax | Dearest way | Its tax | Social Security taxed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2027: their first year, no checks yet | $78,000 | regular account first | $89 | 401(k) first, up to the top of the 12% band | $5,682 | 0% |
| 2033: both checks in | $22,512 | regular account first | $0 | a bit of each | $0 | 6% |
| 2044: Ruth on her own, filing single | $21,312 | a bit of each | $1,369 | 401(k) first, up to the top of the 12% band | $1,736 | 26% |
| 2044 if both were still here, filing jointly | $4,512 | regular account first | $0 | a bit of each | $0 | 7% |
Row 2, 2033: both checks are in, $55,488 a year, and they only need $22,512 from savings. The tax is $0 whichever account they use, because the standard deduction swallows it, and only 6% of the benefit even counts.
Row 3 is the part people miss. In the story Dan dies at 80. In 2044 Ruth is 79, on his bigger check, filing single, and the lines are half as high: 26% of the Social Security is now taxed and she pays $1,369, where the two of them together on the same money (row 4) would pay $0. The 401(k) you leave full for later may be taxed in a year when only one of you is left.
And the required withdrawals? Dan and Ruth were both born after 1960, so theirs start at 75, in 2038. If they keep drawing as above, the 401(k)s hold about $310,000 by then and the required amount is about $12,591, less than they take anyway. Left untouched, the same money would be about $1,129,000, with $45,887 required that year, taxed as income whether they want it or not. Required withdrawals bite the people who don't need the money.
Dan and Ruth Keller are fictional; their figures are illustrative, not advice for you.
Your turn
The Kellers' numbers are in the form, so you can see the three columns before you touch anything. Try one change: switch the year to 2026, or add $20,000 of other income, and watch the tax row move. Then press "Clear the form" and type your own balances and spending. If it's just you, pick "Single" under how you file. The advanced lines are folded away; the three balances and what you spend are enough to start.
The Kellers' numbers are in the form. Type over any of them and the results below become yours. Your numbers stay in this browser; nothing is sent to us.
Empties the balances and income so you can type your own. Birth dates and the year stay.
The answer
To have $78,000 to spend in 2027, Dan and Ruth need $78,000 from savings after the checks and other income. The cheapest way this year is regular account first, at $89 of federal tax. The dearest is 401(k) first, up to the top of the 12% band, at $5,682: a gap of $5,593. The cheapest leaves $626,911 in the 401(k)s; the dearest leaves $576,318, and that difference comes out taxed later.
Required withdrawals: Dan's start at 75, in 2038. Ruth's start at 75, in 2040. Nothing is required yet. Drawing as their pick does, the 401(k)s hold about $635,234 at 75, and the required amount that year is about $25,823. Left untouched, they'd hold $1,128,824, with $45,887 required, taxed as income whether Dan and Ruth need it or not.
| Regular account first | 401(k) first, up to the top of the 12% band | A bit of each | |
|---|---|---|---|
| From the regular account | $45,000 | $0 | $5,015 |
| From 401(k)s and IRAs | $33,089 | $83,682 | $73,551 |
| From Roth accounts | $0 | $0 | $3,900 |
| Federal tax | $89 | $5,682 | $4,466 |
| Taxable income | $23,389 | $51,482 | $43,858 |
| Tax on the next dollar | 10% | 12% | 12% |
| Left in 401(k)s and IRAs | $626,911 | $576,318 | $586,449 |
| Income Medicare will see in 2029 | $55,589 | $83,682 | $76,058 |
Federal only, 2026 figures. Room left in the 12% band under your pick: $99,911 of taxable income. Medicare will read $55,589 for 2029, which is the standard premium (step 6).
The 401(k)s year by year to 90, under your pick
| Age | Year | Opening balance | Required | Taken |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 64 | 2027 | $660,000 | $33,089 | |
| 65 | 2028 | $658,257 | $33,089 | |
| 66 | 2029 | $656,426 | $33,089 | |
| 67 | 2030 | $654,504 | $33,089 | |
| 68 | 2031 | $652,486 | $33,089 | |
| 69 | 2032 | $650,367 | $33,089 | |
| 70 | 2033 | $648,143 | $33,089 | |
| 71 | 2034 | $645,807 | $33,089 | |
| 72 | 2035 | $643,354 | $33,089 | |
| 73 | 2036 | $640,778 | $33,089 | |
| 74 | 2037 | $638,074 | $33,089 | |
| 75 | 2038 | $635,234 | $25,823 | $33,089 |
| 76 | 2039 | $632,253 | $26,677 | $33,089 |
| 77 | 2040 | $629,122 | $27,473 | $33,089 |
| 78 | 2041 | $625,835 | $28,447 | $33,089 |
| 79 | 2042 | $622,383 | $29,497 | $33,089 |
| 80 | 2043 | $618,759 | $30,632 | $33,089 |
| 81 | 2044 | $614,954 | $31,699 | $33,089 |
| 82 | 2045 | $610,959 | $33,025 | $33,089 |
| 83 | 2046 | $606,763 | $34,280 | $34,280 |
| 84 | 2047 | $601,107 | $35,780 | $35,780 |
| 85 | 2048 | $593,593 | $37,100 | $37,100 |
| 86 | 2049 | $584,318 | $38,442 | $38,442 |
| 87 | 2050 | $573,170 | $39,803 | $39,803 |
| 88 | 2051 | $560,035 | $40,878 | $40,878 |
| 89 | 2052 | $545,114 | $42,257 | $42,257 |
| 90 | 2053 | $528,000 | $43,279 | $43,279 |
Grows 5% a year; takes what your pick takes from the 401(k)s this year, or the required amount if that's more. Pre-tax accounts counted as one pot on Dan's clock.
Example 2: Linda, single, no checks yet
We used the calculator again for Linda. She's 62, single, and needs $54,000 in 2027 while her mortgage is still running. She has $250,000 in a 401(k), $20,000 in a Roth and $30,000 in a regular account, half of it gain.
| Regular account first | 401(k) first, up to the top of the 12% band | A bit of each | |
|---|---|---|---|
| From the regular account | $30,000 | $0 | $5,758 |
| From the 401(k) | $24,878 | $58,886 | $47,981 |
| From the Roth | $0 | $0 | $3,838 |
| Federal tax | $878 | $4,886 | $3,578 |
| Taxable income | $23,778 | $42,786 | $34,760 |
Read the tax row: $878 against $4,886. Same idea as the Kellers, half the standard deduction ($16,100), so the free room runs out sooner. Her regular account is small, so the cheap column only works for a year or two; after that it's the 401(k) and the Roth either way.
Linda is fictional, like the Kellers; her figures are illustrative, not advice for you.
Example 3: Tom and Grace, where a pension gets the check taxed
We used the calculator again for Tom and Grace, in 2029. Tom is 68, a full year into his $3,400 check, and his pension pays $30,000. Between them that's nearly their whole $71,523, so they only need $723 from savings.
| With the pension | Without it | |
|---|---|---|
| From savings | $723 | $30,723 |
| Federal tax, cheapest way | $825 | $0 |
| Social Security taxed | 30% | 5% |
Read the last row. With the pension, 30% of Tom's Social Security counts as income and they pay $825; without it, almost none does and the tax is $0. The pension itself is taxed, and it also drags part of the check into tax, because the Social Security test counts every other dollar of income. Nothing to do about it; just where the bill comes from.
Tom and Grace are fictional; their figures are illustrative, not advice for you.
Example 4: Frank, where tax isn't the problem
We used the calculator one more time, for Frank. He claimed at 62, so his check is $1,260 a month, and he needs $15,880 more from his $80,000 401(k) to get to $31,000. He has no other account, so there's only one way to do it.
| Frank | |
|---|---|
| From the 401(k) | $15,880 |
| Federal tax | $0 |
| Social Security taxed | 0% |
Read the tax row: nothing. $15,880 of income sits under the $16,100 standard deduction, and his check is too small to be taxed. For Frank the only question is how long $80,000 lasts at $15,880 a year, which is step 1's sum, not this one. Not everyone needs this page.
Frank is fictional; his figures are illustrative, not advice for you.
What to make of it
- A big gap between the columns this year? Then the order matters, and the cheap column is usually the one that uses up the 0% gains band or the standard deduction.
- A small gap? Then it hardly matters this year, and the 401(k) balance at your start age is the number to watch.
- The part people miss: the cheapest order this year leaves the most in the 401(k), and that comes out taxed later, possibly on top of Social Security and in a year when only one of you is left and filing single.
What this doesn't cover
State income tax, which can be nothing or quite a lot. Roth conversions, which are the next page we'll build. Itemised deductions. Giving to charity straight from an IRA after 70½ (up to $111,000 a year), which counts toward the required amount and isn't taxed. And the 65-and-over deduction is due to end after 2028. Next: step 6, what will Medicare cost, and when does income push it up?
Questions people ask
When do required minimum distributions start?
At 73 if you were born from 1951 to 1959, at 75 if you were born in 1960 or later. For 1959 the regulation says 73 but has not been finalised. The first one can wait until 1 April of the following year; after that, by 31 December each year.
How is an RMD calculated for 2026?
Last year's closing balance divided by the IRS divisor for the age you reach this year: 26.5 at 73, 24.6 at 75, 20.2 at 80. $100,000 at 75 means $4,065. Miss it and the penalty is 25% of the shortfall, 10% if you fix it within two years.
Is Social Security taxable?
Up to 85% of it can be. Add half your benefits to your other income (including tax-exempt interest). Over $32,000 on a joint return ($25,000 single) some is taxed; over $44,000 ($34,000) up to 85% is. Those limits never rise with prices.
Which account should I draw from first in retirement?
This page does not say. It shows what each order costs in federal tax this year and what it leaves in the 401(k) for later, so you can see the trade. The cheapest order this year is often not the cheapest over ten years.
What is the senior deduction?
$6,000 per person aged 65 or over for 2025 to 2028, on top of the standard deduction, shrinking by 6% of income over $150,000 on a joint return ($75,000 single).
Where these numbers come from
Start ages: 26 CFR 1.401(a)(9)-2. The divisor table and the $100,000 example: IRS Publication 590-B. Penalties: IRS, required minimum distributions. Tax on Social Security: IRS Publication 915. 2026 brackets, standard deduction and capital gains thresholds: Rev. Proc. 2025-32. The 65-and-over deduction: IRS, One Big Beautiful Bill Act deductions. Charitable distributions: Notice 2025-67. Figures read from Data Butler's verified us-rates where they exist; checked 31 October 2026.
This is general education with calculators that run on numbers you enter. It is not advice about your situation and not a recommendation to claim, invest, buy or sell anything. The author is not a financial adviser, is not licensed in any state, and has no relationship with you. Social Security's own tools and a flat-fee adviser (see step 7) can check your decision. Your numbers stay in this browser; nothing is sent to us.